Lloyd’s Register report highlights safety risks of uncoordinated alarms on ships

The number of alarms on board ships must be rationalised to ensure they support officers’ and watchkeepers’ operational decision-making capabilities and are not a distraction or irritation, new research conducted by Lloyd’s Register (LR) has found.

Bridge alarm data analysis shows a 197 per cent increase per hour in alarms whilst a vessel is in open sea, compared to nearly two decades ago. The investigation also revealed that there are 70 per cent and six per cent more alarms in coastal waters and confined waters, respectively, compared to 20 years ago.

The research was carried out as part of LR’s “Alarm Management in the Maritime Industry” report drawing on real-world data gathered from 65 watchkeeping officers from 15 ships operated by 10 independent companies. Data collected as part of the investigation were compared with the crew's own perceptions of the impact of alarms on their work.

On the ship’s bridge, peak rates were found to be 74 alarms per hour in a situation requiring high levels of concentration of the navigating officers. For engine room alarms, certain ship segments were experiencing an average of 2,500 machinery alarms per day, with peak daily rates seen at 22,500.

Digitalisation of maritime operations has led to increasing numbers of technologies and sensors being fitted to ships, often with alarm functions. The excessive number of alarms now on board often leads to alarm fatigue and can adversely affect officers’ operational awareness and performance onboard, says the research. There are currently no regulatory instruments mandating justification of the safety credit claimed by alarms.

The study also demonstrates the advantages of alarm systems, and how they can support crews both during normal operations and in demanding situations. It also asserts that alarm frequency should be better monitored and controlled to ensure maximum utility is gained from the software.

Following the results of this investigation, LR and a selection of partners have created an industry task force to research adjacent industry approaches and assess their suitability for managing alarm systems in the maritime context funded by the Danish Maritime Fund.

The report can be downloaded on the LR website.