|Tuesday, 20 December 2011 06:34|
By NEIL BAIRD
Introducing Baird Maritime’s CLEAN SEAS SCORE
Having been involved for many years with a number of the more rational and progressive marine environmental organisations I have often thought that there must be ways in which they can project a stronger voice globally.
A discussion in Hong Kong recently with three leading marine environmentalists inspired the idea of rating various bodies of water. The aim will be to praise and inspire the clean ones and name and shame the "sewer seas".
To launch the idea and try to refine it, I've given scores, ranging from 1 to 100 to a number of rivers, ports, bays, seas and oceans that I have looked at recently. I hope that with contributions from readers we'll be able to credit and condemn on a comprehensive global basis.
The CLEAN SEAS SCORE, will, at first at least, be personal and subjective but still as objective as we can make them. They’ll be rather like the wine ratings accorded by the globally popular and very influential Wine Spectator magazine. We hope that our ratings will be similarly influential and will inspire both thought and action.
The rating system will be based on a simple score ranging from 1 to 100. It will be avowedly unscientific. Thorough scientific evaluation is prone to both delay and corruption. Our ratings will be wide open to rational dispute and argument but the final decision on rating will be mine. I will, of course, try to be absolutely fair.
Every year we will offer a Baird Maritime Award to the authority controlling the cleanest stretch of water and another to its counterpart administering the most improved waterway. We will probably dream up some other award categories in due course, possibly including a wooden spoon!
To get started I list below some bays, ports, seas and waterways that I have visited recently and the scores I have given them:
I’ll be very interested to learn of any comments, disagreements, expansions or improvements you may have. In a few years, I trust, we’ll have a fair, objective and up-to-date rating of all the main seas, straits, bays and waterways on the planet.Adriatic Sea (East) - 92 Aegean Sea - 94 Aberdeen Harbour - 84 Annapolis Harbour - 85 Arabian Gulf - 88 Baltic Sea (West) - 88 Barcelona Port - 82 Bass Strait - 95 Batam Port - 54 Bodrum - 92 Bondi (Sydney) - 83 Bordeaux (Gironde) - 85 Brisbane River - 75 Cairns - 72 Cassus - 90 Cebu (Port) - 62 Chesapeake Estuary - 85 Concarneau - 88 Corfu Town Port - 80 Dalian Port - 70 Fraserburgh - 90 General Santos - 86 Hobart - 93 Ho Chi Minh - 36 Hong Kong (Victoria Harbour) - 50 Hong Kong (Stanley) - 75 Istanbul - 72 Kaliningrad - 54 Kavieng - 88 Launceston (Bell Bay Tasmania) - 90 Legazpi - 48 Loyalty Islands - 96 Macduff - 95 Manila Bay - 6 Marseilles - 93 Miri - 80 Mumbai - 22 New York Harbour - 78 Ningbo - 40 North Sea (North) - 75 North Sea (South) - 68 Noumea - 88 Oslo Fjord - 94 Passig River - 3 Phuket - 64 Piraeus - 44 Port Klang - 52 Port Moresby - 8 Port Phillip - 95 Scrabster - 94 Shanghai - 14 Shenzhen - 40 Sibu - 65 Singapore Port - 65 South Pacific Ocean - 95 Southampton - 86 St Petersburg Port - 64 Surabayu Port - 8 Tanjung Priok (Jakarta) - 4 Venice Lagoon - 80 Western Port - 87 Wuhan - 42 Zhoushan - 18
Latest Book Reviews
- The US Naval Institute on Naval Strategy
- Silent And Unseen: On Patrol in Three Cold War Attack Submarines
- 21st Century Seamanship
- Small Navies: Strategy and Policy for Small Navies in War and Peace
- The Baltimore Sabotage Cell: German Agents, American Traitors, and the U-Boat Deutschland During World War I
- Re-Inventing The Ship: Science, Technology and the Maritime World, 1800-1918
- The Indian Ocean and US Grand Strategy: Ensuring Access And Promoting Security
Latest CommentsLeonardo Alphonso: I am given to understand this book is useful for marine engineers for learning about purification of...
david wood ross: Excellent timely article Neil and accurately reflects my own experience. I say timely because recent...
Ross Fletcher: Well said.Needs a lot more noise on this issue. As a professional merchant navy Officer, I have been...
John Oscroft: Try the Barrow in Furness (UK) museum, housed in an old dry dock, whilst a lot is given over to the ...